18th Dec 1920 Partick Thistle 2 Dundee 1 (SFL - game 22)


45y born in Scotland man-george-easton.jpg George Easton Manager(s) Sandy MacFarlane
Andrew Kerr mh-in.png
Jimmy McMenemy mh-out.png
Tom Gibbon (1-0, og 65 mins); Andrew Kerr (2-1, 68 mins) mh-goal.png William MacLean (1-1, 67 mins)
mh-red-card.png
28y, 3m, 12d Scotland kenny-campbell.jpg Kenny Campbell mh-01.png Tom Gibbon
27y, 5m, 20d Scotland tom-crichton.jpg Tom Crichton mh-02.png David Raitt
37y, 10m, 0d Scotland willie-bulloch.jpg Willie Bulloch mh-03.png David Thomson
27y, 8m, 29d Scotland joe-harris.jpg Joe Harris mh-04.png David Hutchison
31y, 2m, 9d Scotland willie-hamilton.jpg Willie Hamilton mh-05.png David Nicoll
26y, 10m, 11d Scotland jimmy-mcmullan.jpg Jimmy McMullan mh-06.png John Jackson
23y, 5m, 21d Scotland john-blair.jpg John Blair mh-07.png John Honeyman
22y, 8m, 4d Scotland jimmy-kinloch.jpg Jimmy Kinloch mh-08.png William MacLean
Scotland andrew-kerr.jpg Andrew Kerr mh-09.png George Philip
Scotland alex-lauder.jpg Alex Lauder mh-10.png David McDonald
21y, 9m, 25d Scotland willie-salisbury.jpg Willie Salisbury mh-11.png Alex Troup
27y, 5m, 25d Age

notes
  • OH has John Blair for both of Thistle's goals, but we say he got neither, although GH say John Blair (who took the corner) got the first. Everybody was confused about the first goal in the dense fog. The SP reporter says he got the first goalscorer directly from the ref, and reported that a Dundee back kicked the ball against his own goalie (Thomas Gibbon) and it went in. However, the DR scribe spoke to the Thistle players after the game and they reported that the ref gave a goal as he thought the keeper had caught the header (?) (by Dundee's Raitt) on the wrong side of the goal line. For sure it looks like one, if not two people touched the ball after Blair took the corner, so it's not his goal. We go with the referee's view, although who knows for sure? The second goal was reported as Andrew Kerr's, from a pass by John Blair in SC/SP/GH/DR. JL concurs. We therefore go with the referee's “truth” for the first one (Gibbon og) and the majority view for the second (Kerr).

Info match hubs
© The Thistle Archive 2015-2025. All rights reserved. Third-party trademarks and content are the property of their respective owners, and subject to their own copyright terms and conditions. See the website links provided in each case.