yany2.jpg Your Archive Needs YOU! Page upload volunteers are urgently required; free time is precious for everyone but if you can spare some then please do get in touch → and play your part in helping to build an Archive for all of Jagskind to use and enjoy! Read more →


? In
? Out
David Hislop (1-0, 1st half); Sam Clark (2-0, 1st half); Roddy McLeod (3-2, 1st half); Willie Paul (2nd half); Andrew Johnston (2nd half) Scorer(s) William McBain (2-1, 1st half); James Morrison (2-2, 1st half)
Sending Off(s)
22y, 7m, 13d Scotland john-mccorkindale.jpg John McCorkindale Goalkeeper James Cameron
24y, 2m, 16d Scotland william-proudfoot.jpg William Proudfoot no. 2 Richard Hunter
23y, 8m, 4d Scotland thomas-mcculloch.jpg Thomas McCulloch no. 3 Robert McFarlane
Scotland george-gorham.jpg George Gorham no. 4 Killin
20y, 8m, 10d Scotland archie-freebairn.jpg Archie Freebairn no. 5 Andrew Brown
24y, 10m, 21d Scotland bob-robertson.jpg Bob Robertson no. 6 Edward McBain
19y, 7m, 0d Scotland david-hislop.jpg David Hislop no. 7 James Morrison
24y, 6m, 0d Scotland andrew-johnston.jpg Andrew Johnston no. 8 Thomson
24y, 2m, 5d Scotland willie-paul.jpg Willie Paul no. 9 William McBain
Scotland sam-clark.jpg Sam Clark no. 10 Harry Brandon
19y, 3m, 30d Scotland roddy-mcleod.jpg Roddy McLeod no. 11 James Dunlop
22y, 7m, 17d Age

teamline notes
  • Teamlines per GH, OH concurs.
dubious goals panel
  • OH (in no order) credits David Hislop, Willie Paul & Roddy McLeod as scorers, with 2 missing. After analyzing as many papers as we can, we've added Sam Clark & Andrew Johnston as the missing scorers, although we've resorted to taking the unusual step of relying on statements which are inferral rather than explicit. In terms of sequence, Hislop and McLeod are unopposed with the first and third, but the second is up for debate. Whilst the GH credits Willie Paul, both the SR and SCL have it as Sam Clark, so we side with the latter on the 2:1 contemporary basis. Away from the match report, the SR editorial reads that "Sam Clark filled the position creditably. Paul and Johnston were on good form." This adds further fuel to Paul having scored at least once. Looking at the whole picture, we've decided to make the educated guess that Johnston and Paul, on good form, were the two second half scorers, and will happily change should we ever find any contemporary evidence to the contrary.

Info match hubs

question-mark.png If you can help to answer any of these marked questions, then please do get in touch →

match
© The Thistle Archive 2015-2024. All rights reserved. Third-party trademarks and content are the property of their respective owners, and subject to their own copyright terms and conditions. See the website links provided in each case.